Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Presbyterians say gay marriage OK

who's talking here?

wayward1 8
* 2
SoupIsGoodFood 3
reh6110 1
Work in Progress 25
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Devil in a Blue Dress 1
Joe Blow 1
WatchOut 2
Emperor of Kingwood 1
a889324uu 2
Plain Bellied Sneetch 1
Butterbean 18
You can call me Michelle 3
jacobson 30
AMDG 25
logic 1
JuanSequin 3
Impiety 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Wayta go, church folk.

Something to help KU sleep better.

Gay OK 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

There is a way that seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof, are the ways of death.

Proverbs 14:12 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

lol, but are Presbyterians REAL Christians according to the KU Zealots? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Is this all you people obsess about? 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Well, for those of us who care about this sort of thing, it's a really sad thing to see. Some of the greatest Christian minds of the past few centuries were Presbyterians, and it is very troubling to witness the slide of this once great denomination into complete apostasy (or at least this sect of it, I think that some broke off much earlier when they saw the direction Presb. USA has been heading for decades.)

We can pray that they will repent and return. It feels like a rip in the family, and it is. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

are Presbyterians REAL Christians

It is obvious that they aren't. You can't be a Christian and deliberately sanction something that is against God's Word and contrary to His institution.

They are just a religious entity trying to pose as Christian. Just another religious entity whose people have allowed satan in. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

The Bible uses the metaphor of a cheating spouse a lot when dealing with God's relationship to mankind (and Israel in particular), and I think it is apt here.

Watching the decline of the Presbyterian Church is like having an adult sibling who is cheating on their spouse. You can't stop them from doing it, but you know that they are self destructing, and it grieves your heart, and you just have to pray that they repent and return. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Watching the decline of the Presbyterian Church

That decline started last year when they started ordaining gays and allowed their ministers to preside over gay marriages. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

they are self destructing, and it grieves your heart

Because they won't see the Kingdom of Heaven. 1 Corinthians 6:9-10 

JuanSequin --- 11 years ago -

The Presbys haven't been relevant for at least 30 years. They have consistently caved to the political and economic winds for years. A country club membership would yield better returns. They are the epitomy of go along to get along.

True Christianity can be offensive. It's designed that way. Christians are instructed to be separate from this world.

Jesus was not a wallflower and that's exactly what the Presbys have been for a long time. They are not the only guilty denomination. Most have watered down Christianity over the years. Christians are ultimately responsible for the moral decline in the US. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Christians are ultimately responsible for the moral decline in the US.

Yes, because they have accepted people who claim to be Christian, but aren't, as Christians. 

JuanSequin --- 11 years ago -

Agreed, I think. Too many Christians have given ground to appease and maintain their own lifestyles. Speaking for myself of course, not the best Christian example. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

All good points. I think it started with good intentions. I see it happening now even in my own denomination. People, at least that I know, are earnestly attempting to reach the lost where they are. But you have to hold so tight to Jesus as your life boat, tethered by scripture to the main ship, lest you slip under the water yourself in an attempt to reach out to others.

We have to get the message out there, and that involves being missionaries out to the real world, but we cannot become like the world and still have a message worth giving. Christianity is radical, and it does clash with the culture. It has a long history of going against what is popular.

I struggle with it all of the time. We all desire to be "liked." We're social beings. But true Christians are going to offend people. They found Jesus so offensive that they crucified him. We're going to get people upset when we do what we are supposed to do--which is speak truth to whoever will listen. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Soup, about as obsessed as you with your constant need to inject yourself into every single thread on homosexuality. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

This does sadden me, but it does not surprise me. Relativism is an inevitable outcome of the protestant revolution.

Inevitably, without the Divine Revelation of tradition, there will be human interpretation of scripture and it will bend and twist with whatever the prevailing winds are.

We continue to pray for Christian unity, and wait for our brothers and sisters to join us in full communion with the one catholic and Apostolic Church. 

Plain Bellied Sneetch --- 11 years ago -

Some of the greatest Christian minds

If you are not smarter than all of those "great minds," then how do you know whether those welcoming others into their church now, despite the past ignorance of their denomination, are not the greatest minds yet?

Just another religious entity whose people have allowed satan in.

Did somebody say "Satan"?

"Well, Elaine, let's examine the word "Santa", shall we? [holds up board with "SANTA" spelled across it in removeable letters] Santa. Let's see, what have we got here? We've got an S and an A, an N, a T, and another A. Hmm.. [rearranges the letters] Who could be causing all those laps to bounce up and down curiously? Who would help grown men peel the focus from the baby Jesus on his birthday? Who could it be, I just don't know. Could it be.. [echo] Satan!!"
--Churchlady

Christianity is radical
Amen, Sister! Death to all Infidels! Seriously? 

You can call me Michelle --- 11 years ago -

There are three main denominations of Presbyterian in the United States. PCUSA is practically polar opposite of PCA.

The Presbyterian Church USA is extremely liberal. The Presbyterian Church Missouri Synod is a bit liberal, more than the Presbyterian Church in America. The PCA is very conservative. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

--Churchlady

Another low information voter that doesn't know SNL is humor. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

There are three main denominations of Presbyterian in the United States. PCUSA is practically polar opposite of PCA.

The Presbyterian Church USA is extremely liberal. The Presbyterian Church Missouri Synod is a bit liberal, more than the Presbyterian Church in America. The PCA is very conservative.


And maybe a few thousand other protestant schisms out there - all firmly believing in sole scriptura - differently. And all firmly believing they are not privately interpreting the Bible. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

It's odd. The one religion that believes homosexuals should be outright killed is the one religion a certain group of KU conservative/christian haters can't seem to condemn - Islam. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

It's the PCUSA that made the ruling. Not all Presbyterians. It's the largest group of Presbyterians but it is breaking up rapidly. And no real protestant pays any real attention to what the denomination leaders say from their removed offices. They could say the Earth was populated by Martians and it wouldn't impact what happens in the pews in Kingwood one bit. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

And no real protestant pays any real attention to what the denomination leaders say from their removed offices.

Wayward - this is not an attack, but a real question. I agree with your point above, because the leaders of all protestant denominations are only there on the authority of man. But then why have them in the first place??

I know I am being particularly aggressive on this issue. I also know I am not going to immediately change any minds. That is not my purpose. But I would like my good Christian brothers and sisters who are not in communion with the Church, to stop for a second and consider Catholicism. Do you really know what it teaches, or do you just think you do ?

I will stop the harangue here. But this particular news story does point to one of the primary weaknesses in Protestantism and, with I hope a pure heart, - I just wanted to point it out. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

This does sadden me, but it does not surprise me. Relativism is an inevitable outcome of the protestant revolution.

Inevitably, without the Divine Revelation of tradition, there will be human interpretation of scripture and it will bend and twist with whatever the prevailing winds are.

We continue to pray for Christian unity, and wait for our brothers and sisters to join us in full communion with the one catholic and Apostolic Church.


Absolute nonsense.

all firmly believing in sole scriptura - differently. And all firmly believing they are not privately interpreting the Bible.

LOL, that's exactly what the Catholic church has done by not believing in sola scriptura - even going so far as to change Scripture and believing in false doctrines that contradict Scripture because of their own interpretations. 

reh6110 --- 11 years ago -

Not all Presbyterians have approved this just PCUSA. There are several other Presbyterian groups who left PCUSA because they did not want this. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

the leaders of all protestant denominations are only there on the authority of man. But then why have them in the first place??

Good point. The denomination leaders (I'll pick on Presbyterians) are chosen by man, but have extremely limited power. They do not run church business. They do not choose ministers. They run the admin office of the denomination. The churches themselves decide who their leaders are. They run their own business affairs; they pay their own bills and pick the sermons. The denomination is absent from the day-to-day life a member experiences in the pews. So a Presbyterian church in Kingwood is under no obligation to change anything in operations or teaching to accommodate the views of the denomination.
So, "why have them in the first place?? Their role is admin in nature and helps run an organization that?s nationwide. But competition from smaller, more conservative denominations are rapidly pulling Presbyterian churches away from the larger PCUSA.

top for a second and consider Catholicism. Do you really know what it teaches, or do you just think you do ?

I think most everyone, whether they love it or revile it, knows exactly the Catholic Church teaches. But I assure you, the most vocal, anti gay movements in the country are tied up in the protestant Christian coalition. While I certainly wouldn't knock any attempt to recruit to the Catholic fold, doing so under the premise of being more anti gay just doesn't hold much weight. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I think most everyone, whether they love it or revile it, knows exactly the Catholic Church teaches

That I would disagree with, I am not even that sure that most Catholics know exactly what the Catholic Church teaches.

doing so under the premise of being more anti gay just doesn't hold much weight.

Being more anti gay is not the point I was making. The point was the divergent views/theologies of multiple protestant churches, while each believing their position is anchored in the same scripture, which they are not interpreting. There is a break in logic and reason there. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

Being more anti gay is not the point I was making. The point was the divergent views/theologies of multiple protestant churches, while each believing their position is anchored in the same scripture, which they are not interpreting. There is a break in logic and reason there.?

Ah, I see. One thing to remember with protestant churches is that there isn't a centralized power structure like the Catholic church. So while it appears that the "leadership" is saying something that differs from what the churches teach or from scripture. It's really just a minority group that doesn't have any power or represent what is taught in the pews.

It's like a Republican politician saying he's pro choice. It doesn't represent the body as a whole. And then supporters disconnect from him. The teaching in churches hasn't been and will not be affected on bit by what a denomination leader says. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

LOL, that's exactly what the Catholic church has done by not believing in sola scriptura

The Catholic Church existed for 1500 years before there was even a concept of
sola scriptura, and the first 300 or so before there was even an agreed cannon of the New Testament.

Sola Scriptura is an idea of man, it is not a concept that the Catholic Church even has the ability to decide to accept or not. It would required the nullification of a matter of settled dogma, there is no provision in the Catholic Church which allows for that. For us, that would like saying, God made a mistake. It is not possible.

I know these concepts are very foreign to you. You are deeply rooted in your beliefs, and that is admirable. But you know very very little about Catholicism. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

But you know very very little about Catholicism.?

I think people know the results, but not how they came to be. Many people know the non-biblical beliefs of Catholics. But not where they came from or who made them dogma. Whether it's the assumption of Mary or the Immaculate Conception for instance, non Catholics don't know how these concepts became religious facts. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Ah, I see. One thing to remember with protestant churches is that there isn't a centralized power structure like the Catholic church.

That is exactly the point. As a catholic, I am prohibited from any interpretation of the scripture that is in conflict the dogmatic teachings of the church, or that which has been explicitly interpreted by the magisterium.

We do have a final arbiter on what we must believe, to be Catholic. And, we believe that is God, acting directly through the Pope, or the entirety of the bishops, or the magisterium with the Pope's blessing, on matters of faith and morals.

We believe this infallibility is God's gift to his church to preserve it from errors in matters of faith and morals.

On these types of issues we have no choice. To be Catholic, you must believe them. If you do not believe them, you are not Catholic. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I think people know the results, but not how they came to be. Many people know the non-biblical beliefs of Catholics. But not where they came from or who made them dogma. Whether it's the assumption of Mary or the Immaculate Conception for instance, non Catholics don't know how these concepts became religious facts.

Completely agree, and while there are some dogmatic beliefs that are non-scriptural. It is an important point that none are anti-scriptural. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

That is exactly the point. As a catholic, I am prohibited from any interpretation of the scripture that is in conflict the dogmatic teachings of the church, or that which has been explicitly interpreted by the magisterium.

By "power structure" I didn't mean scriptural interpretation, I meant the running of operations. All Christian denominations be them Anglican, Catholic or Methodist, all have strict codes of scriptural belief. Some times, people stray in their interpretations or actions. You have excommunication for instance for these people. Protestants don't have a central power to excomm so they just ignore the fools and distance them. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Wayta go, church folk.

According to the article: 1.8 million members, 10,000 congregations. The guiding body voted.

Whether or not one chooses to minimalize the impact,that's a lot, sports fans. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Because they won't see the Kingdom of Heaven. 1 Corinthians 6:9-10


As if you really care. With the way you talk to people here I'm surprised you don't off everyone who disagrees with you till the cheese stands alone. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Thanks Wayward - as much as I do enjoy to argue/discuss theology. Maybe too much. I don't want this to be me trying to convince you or anyone else about what I consider the truth of Catholicism by the weight of my argument.

Hoping that my fervor for it, and the way I try ( and often fail ) to live it, may make someone think it is worth learning a little something about.

And thanks for clearing up for me some of the workings of your Church - of which I freely admit I know very little. 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

Hats off to your AMDG. Good talking with you. Class all around. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The Catholic Church existed for 1500 years before there was even a concept of
sola scriptura, and the first 300 or so before there was even an agreed cannon of the New Testament.


Absolute nonsense. You really should quit making those false statements.


That is exactly the point. As a catholic, I am prohibited from any interpretation of the scripture that is in conflict the dogmatic teachings of the church, or that which has been explicitly interpreted by the magisterium.

Which definitely goes against Scripture.


We do have a final arbiter on what we must believe, to be Catholic. And, we believe that is God, acting directly through the Pope, or the entirety of the bishops, or the magisterium with the Pope's blessing, on matters of faith and morals.

Definitely not Scriptural. The whole purpose of God having the veil of the temple "rent in twain from the top to the bottom" was to let us know that we could go DIRECTLY to God through Jesus Christ. A human priest was NO LONGER NEEDED.


Completely agree, and while there are some dogmatic beliefs that are non-scriptural. It is an important point that none are anti-scriptural.

There are MANY Catholic dogmatic beliefs that are anti-Scriptural, and in reality, if they are non-Scriptural, then they are ADDITIONS which make them anti-Scriptural by definition. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

There are MANY Catholic dogmatic beliefs that are anti-Scriptural,

name one please 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

That Mary is Co-Redemptrix. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Mary as co-redemptrix is a doctrine not a dogma.

The Church does not teach (never has and never will) that Mary as Co-redemptrix is equal to Christ. "Co" is from the Latin "cum," meaning "with". "Trix" is a feminine suffix, so the word means "the woman with the Redeemer" - the woman with the one doing the act of redemption..

Nothing in the Bible that I know off says Mary was not with the Redeemer.

Got another ? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground