Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

SCOTUS: The Women Take Over in Texas Abortion Case

who's talking here?

smartypants 15
SoupIsGoodFood 15
Red Heifer 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 17
Dr Aborto 1
Dorothy Parker 20
Miss Understanding 4
Joe Blow 9
3rd generation hippie 2
DatBoyHooD 4
Emperor of Kingwood 24
witchywoman 2
a889324uu 6
Not KU 4
Butterbean 2
mutton 15
AMDG 33
fuzz81 27
Karras 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

witchywoman --- 10 years ago -

The Women Take Over


In oral arguments for the Texas abortion case, the three female justices upend the Supreme Court?s balance of power.




When the Supreme Court last heard oral arguments in a landmark abortion case, it was April 1992, the case was Planned Parenthood v Casey, and Sandra Day O?Connor was the lone female justice.

Twenty-four years later, there are three women on the court. And if you count Justice Stephen Breyer as one of history?s great feminists?and I do?then you can view the arguments in this term?s landmark abortion case, Whole Woman?s Health v Hellerstedt, as creating a neat 4?4 split. On one side, you have a group of testy male justices needling a female lawyer for Texas clinics about whether it was even appropriate for them to hear this appeal. On the other, you?ve got four absolutely smoking hot feminists pounding on Texas? solicitor general for passing abortion regulations that have no plausible health purpose and also seem pretty stupid.

It felt as if, for the first time in history, the gender playing field at the high court was finally leveled, and as a consequence the court?s female justices were emboldened to just ignore the rules. Time limits were flouted to such a degree that Chief Justice John Roberts pretty much gave up enforcing them. I counted two instances in which Roberts tried to get advocates to wrap up as Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor simply blew past him with more questions. There was something wonderful and symbolic about Roberts losing almost complete control over the court?s indignant women, who are just not inclined to play nice anymore.

The case involves a crucial constitutional challenge to two provisions in Texas? HB 2, the state?s omnibus abortion bill from 2013. The first requires doctors to obtain admitting privileges from a hospital 30 miles from the clinic where they perform abortions; the second requires abortion clinics to be elaborately retrofitted to comply with building regulations that would make them ?ambulatory surgical centers.? If these provisions go into full effect, Texas would see a 75 percent reduction in the number of clinics serving 5.4 million women of childbearing age. The constitutional question is whether having 10 clinics to serve all these women, including many who would live 200 miles away from the nearest facility, represents an ?undue burden? on the right to abortion deemed impermissible after the Casey decision. Each of the female justices takes a whacking stick to the very notion that abortion?one of the safest procedures on record?requires rural women to haul arse across land masses larger than the whole state of California in order to take a pill, in the presence of a doctor, in a surgical theater.

The morning starts with an arcane and technical debate that eats up most of Stephanie Toti?s time. Toti, arguing on behalf on the Texas clinics, first has to answer an argument?raised by Ginsburg?that the clinics were precluded from even bringing some of their claims. Between this and factual challenges from Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito as to whether there was any evidence on the record to show that the law itself triggered the closings of Texas clinics, she doesn?t have much time to get to the merits. So frustrated is Justice Elena Kagan by the conservatives? repeated insistence that perhaps the clinics just coincidentally all closed within days of HB 2?s passage that she finally has to intervene. ?Is it right,? she asks Toti, ?that in the two­-week period that the ASC requirement was in effect, that over a dozen facilities shut their doors, and then when that was stayed, when that was lifted, they reopened again immediately?? Toti agrees. ?It's almost like the perfect controlled experiment,? continues Kagan, ?as to the effect of the law, isn?t it? It?s like you put the law into effect, 12 clinics closed. You take the law out of effect, they reopen??

Here is where Justice Anthony Kennedy, who clearly holds the whole of Texas in his hands, first suggests that it might be ?proper? and ?helpful? for the court to remand this back to the lower courts for hearings, to address questions about the capacity of the remaining clinics to fill the state?s needs.

If the case does get bounced back, the Supreme Court can hear it again another day. This is not great news for the women of Texas, but at least it wouldn?t drive a stake through the heart of Roe.

Roberts spends a good deal of Toti?s remaining time suggesting that the ?undue burden? test after Casey has nothing to do with the state?s purpose in passing the law. Toti replies that the court looked carefully at the state?s intent when it assessed the abortion regulations in Casey. At around this point, Sotomayor decides that she has some things to say: ?There?s two types of early abortion­­ at play here. The medical abortion, that doesn't involve any hospital procedure. A doctor prescribes two pills, and the women take the pills at home, correct?? Toti explains that the woman has to take them at the abortion facility under Texas law.

Sotomayor is back: ?I'm sorry. What? She has to come back two separate days to take them? ... When she could take it at home, it?s­­ now she has to travel 200 miles or pay for a hotel to get those two days of treatment??

Toti confirms that there is no reputable evidence that there is a medical benefit to having a medication abortion at ?a ­multi-million­-dollar surgical facility.?

Sotomayor asks for more time to finish her two-part question and the chief justice nods, resigned. Then Sotomayor asks why a dilation and curettage associated with a miscarriage can be performed in a doctor?s office whereas a basically identical D&C must be performed in an ambulatory surgical center when it?s for an abortion. Toti replies, and Sotomayor keeps talking. The chief thanks Toti but Sotomayor forges on, wondering if any other medical procedures require taking pills in a hospital. No, says Toti. Sotomayor is finally content to rest her case.

Solicitor General Don Verrilli will probably not get adequate credit for giving a nearly flawless 10-minute argument Wednesday morning on behalf of the Obama administration. He opens with the most succinct recitation of the issue so far: ?This law closes most abortion facilities in the state, puts extreme stress on the few facilities that remain open, and exponentially increases the obstacles confronting women who seek abortions in the state. And it does all of that on the basis of a medical justification that cannot withstand any meaningful scrutiny that the American Medical Association has told you is groundless and that the district court found will actually operate in practice to increase health risks to women.?

Justice Samuel Alito is having none of it. ?Many of [the regulations] have ? to do with basic safety. They don?t even have anything to do, in particular, with abortion. So the entrances to the clinic have to be at grade level. You have to have an elevator. The ­­corridors have to be wide enough so that you could bring in a stretcher.? Later Alito will suggest that ?Whole Woman?s facilities have been cited for really appalling violations when they were inspected. Holes in the floor where ­­rats could come in.? (This gives whole new meaning to the phrase TRAP laws.)

Verrilli closes by cautioning the justices about eviscerating the very right preserved in Casey: ?If you do find that this law is upheld, what you will be saying is that this right really only exists in theory and not in fact.

The remainder of the argument basically just consists of the four liberal justices pounding away on Texas Solicitor General Scott Keller.

Ginsburg begins by asking Keller how many Texas women live more than 100 miles from an abortion clinic. When he tells her that women in El Paso can hop over the border to New Mexico, she stops him short. ?That?s odd,? she muses, ?that you point to the New Mexico facility. New Mexico doesn't have any surgical ASC requirement, and it doesn't have any admitting requirement. So if your argument is right, then New Mexico is not an available way out for Texas because Texas says to protect our women, we need these things.? (This is where I want to call up each of the men who demanded that Ginsburg retire in 2014 and just smile, and smile, and smile.)

Sotomyor tags in: ?According to you, the slightest health improvement is enough to impose on hundreds of thousands of women.­­ Even assuming I accept your argument, which I don't, necessarily, because it?s being challenged, but the slightest benefit is enough to burden the lives of a million women. That?s your point??

Ginsburg: ?I can't imagine. What is the benefit of having a woman take those pills in an ambulatory surgical center when there is no surgery involved??

Then Kennedy asks Keller a surprising question: Is the effect of this law ?to increase surgical abortions as distinct from medical abortions,? he wonders, because ?this may not be medically wise.?

Now it?s over to Breyer: ?There are two laws. I am focusing on the first law. The first law says that a doctor at the abortion clinic must have admitting privileges in a hospital ? nearby, right?? Yes, says Keller. ?Where in the record will I find evidence of women who had complications, who could not get to a hospital, even though there was a working transfer arrangement ? because the doctor himself has to have admitting privileges? Which were the women? On what page does it tell me their names, what the complications were, and why that happened??

Keller replies that this isn?t in the record. Breyer continues, ?So Judge Posner then seems to be correct where he says he could find in the entire nation, in his opinion, only one arguable example of such a thing, and he?s not certain that even that one is correct.? Breyer leans in, ?What is the benefit to the woman of a procedure that is going to cure a problem of which there is not one single instance in the nation, though perhaps there is one, but not in Texas.? People laugh.

Kagan wonders whether the Texas legislature can demand that every abortion clinic must conform to the standards of Massachusetts General, since that would undoubtedly increase health benefits. ?because MGH, it?s a great hospital.?

This affords Kennedy the opportunity to add, importantly, ?Doesn?t that show that the undue­ burden test is weighed against what the state?s interest is??

Then it?s Kagan who moves in. Calmly, poker-faced, she asks Keller: ?You said that as the law is now ? Texas is allowed to set much, much higher medical standards, whether it has to do with the personnel or procedures or the facilities themselves, higher medical standards ? for abortion facilities than for facilities that do any other kind of medical work, even much more risky medical work? Am I right??

Keller agrees. Then Kagan asks: ?And I guess I just want to know, why would Texas do that?? The room erupts. Keller says complications. Kagan says that liposuction actually has greater complications. Keller says Kermit Gosnell. Kagan says nothing that happened in the Gosnell case could have occurred under Texas? pre-existing regulations. Sotomayor says colonoscopies have more complications. Finally, Keller says, ?But legislatures react to topics that are of public concern.? And that is what matters. Not women?s health. Politics.

At this point in the transcript?Page 70?we find Justice Kennedy saying, ?Sonia is off.? I didn?t hear that in the court?everyone was talking over everything. On Friday, when the audio is released, we can figure out what that means. Meanwhile, let?s just have fun with it.

Keller is now way over his time, but Ginsburg can?t stop herself from asking: ?Earlier in your argument, you were quoting how many women are within a reasonable range of the clinic. But don't we know from Casey that the focus must be on the ones who are burdened??

Keller tries to reply that laws regulating women?such as Casey?s spousal notification provision, which was deemed unconstitutional?are different from the Texas law, which only concerns ?doctor and clinic regulations.? Ginsburg the feminist legend is now incredulous: ?But this is about ­­? a woman has a fundamental right to make this choice for herself. ?

John Roberts practically has to manhandle Keller into sitting down. Ginsburg, it appears, was only getting started.


Looming over most of the morning, of course, is Justice Scalia, who is three times larger in his absence than even his outsize presence used to be. Scalia, recall, once referred to clinics in an opinion announcement as ?abortion mills.? Justice Alito seems exhausted trying to play both his own part, and Scalia?s, and Justice Clarence Thomas, silent today, chatters and laughs with Breyer. One senses that the chief justice, two weeks into this new post-Scalia era, is worn out just trying to keep the women at bay. And with today?s facts in hand, the pugilistic culture warrior Scalia would have been incomparable. Without him on the bench, the court?s conservative wing is reduced to demanding more and more proof that the closure of 11 clinics on the day HB 2 passed was really a result of the law. This is, as Scalia would never say, weak applesauce.


If the case is sent back to Texas on remand, we will play this out again in a few years with nine justices. But it?s hard to imagine President Obama conjuring up, from even the darkest, most devious underground lab, a new justice who would be half as fierce as the four-car train of whoop arse we saw today. 

Red Heifer --- 10 years ago -

They were brilliant. It is almost like they are daring the rest of the court to try to justify the state's case. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

what a great day it was, for women's rights! HERE, HERE!! 

Miss Understanding --- 10 years ago -

The Women Take Over



What a great article! Thank you for posting so much!!!


GO GIRLS!!!

GO H I L L A R Y!

GO TRUMP! You will guarantee a win for The HILL! 

Miss Understanding --- 10 years ago -

what a great day it was, for women's rights! HERE, HERE!!



Old fogey farty men justices be damned! 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Yea! Women can kill their unborn children! Y'all are sick.

Don't want a baby, hold a penny with your knees until you are married. 

Dr Aborto --- 10 years ago -

hold a penny with your knees until you are married.?

0 

Miss Understanding --- 10 years ago -

Don't want a baby, hold a penny with your knees until you are married.


Don't want an abortion, don't have one!

Guess what, it is legally allowed in the USA!!! You want to take away my right to an abortion, I will take away your guns. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Don't want an abortion, don't have one

Exactly.

Hilarious that republicans want "small government" that doesn't interfere. They want government to be just small enough to fit in every woman's vagina. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

that's called selective small government- that's when the party started losing me- this isn't the pub party my dad staunchly believed in. Who are these people? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Won't get too involved - but must add a these few points:

1. A human fetus is completely alive, by any biological definition of alive.

2. A human fetus is completely human, it is no other possibility

3. It is in complete possession of a unique human future.

IMO opinion it is immoral to deny an innocent unique human life of its future, no matter the rational. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Not without a host. The living, conscious host isn't obligated to provide for it. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

this isn't the pub party my dad staunchly believed in

Maybe disposable (unborn) babies wasn't as prevalent in your dad's day.

You want to take away my right to an abortion

And you want to take the rights of an unborn child. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Not without a host. The living, conscious host isn't obligated to provide for it.

I think that depends.

Fuzz, let's say you have a rare blood disease and only a 9 month constant blood transfusion from me can keep you alive. It may be a good thing to do for me to keep you alive, but I do not think I have a moral obligation to.

Now lets change this to, I willfully gave you this disease through my willful action. Now, I think I do have a moral obligation to do what is in my power to keep you from dying from that disease.

IMO by willfully engaging in sex, there is a known and possible outcome of a new human life being formed, I think the mother has an obligation by her action to that life. 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

that's called selective small government- that's when the party started losing me-


Right on Tat Lady!



this isn't the pub party my dad staunchly believed in. Who are these people?

They are the Pubies!!! They are divisive, uninclusive, arrogant, nutjob obstructionists who think they have large phalluses and are flinging them around in debates. They don't believe in compromise and want everything their way or refuse to allow the government anything. They love war and guns and giving all the big contracts to 'connections' within their own party higher ups. They want their gun rights but refuse women their legal right to terminate a pregnancy if they so desire.
LMFAO 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Now lets change this to, I willfully gave you this disease through my willful action. Now, I think I do have a moral obligation to do what is in my power to keep you from dying from that disease

I'm not getting into this today.. Too busy. But I'll respond to this.

Imagine your analogy in another way. Should a woman willingly bring a child into an environment that isn't best for the child? Poverty, physical spousal abuse, drug abuse, mental illness issues, etc?

Now I know how you'll respond with a rainbow and lollypop response that all life is prescious and viable, yadda yadda, but in my opinion a woman who determines she is incapable of raising a child in a healthy environment is making the right choice. And it is her choice to make, based on her unique situation. It's not your choice to make. 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

Now I know how you'll respond with a rainbow and lollypop response that all life is prescious and viable, yadda yadda, but in my opinion a woman who determines she is incapable of raising a child in a healthy environment is making the right choice. And it is her choice to make, based on her unique situation. It's not your choice to make.


Amen.

Let's not forget that terminating a pregnancy is LEGAL IN THE US WHETHER YOU LIKE IT OR NOT. Just like your goddamn guns. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I'm not getting into this today.. Too busy. But I'll respond to this.

I agree - it is a do loop - just wanted to make the point.

Imagine your analogy in another way. Should a woman willingly bring a child into an environment that isn't best for the child? Poverty, physical spousal abuse, drug abuse, mental illness issues, etc?

Yes, as opposed to killing it.

Now I know how you'll respond with a rainbow and lollypop response that all life is prescious and viable, yadda yadda, but in my opinion a woman who determines she is incapable of raising a child in a healthy environment is making the right choice. And it is her choice to make, based on her unique situation. It's not your choice to make


All human life is precious - if you think that is lollypop and rainbows - I beg to differ -

And it is her choice to make - her choice was to do all she could to prevent an unwanted pregnancy. IMO - it is no humans choice to end an innocent life.

We as humans have a long history of deciding who is or is not human - the unborn are just the latest group to the list.

I'm done Fuzz - you may have the last word if you wish. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Nah, I'm good. We are both entitled to our different opinions. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

exactly. We are all entitled to our opinions. Now if everyone would remember that, we'd have a much more interesting site- 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Black Lives Matter............ well, maybe not in this case. 

Miss Understanding --- 10 years ago -

WOOOW, talk about in poor taste. You have beaten your previous best Souper. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Yawn. Go find a Kardashian. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

Soup, it's not just black women who have abortions- what most pro life people don't know about is what happens to the unwanted babies who are born- when you read about a boyfriend beating a toddler to death, or kids going in to the system, and being abused, so when they grow up, (if they do) they become criminals- this is reality- the end result is seldom pretty- children suffer- sometimes the lucky ones are never born. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Soup, it's not just black women who have abortions-

You don't say. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

what most pro life people don't know about is what happens to the unwanted babies who are born- when you read about a boyfriend beating a toddler to death, or kids going in to the system, and being abused, so when they grow up, (if they do) they become criminals

So.......... what you're saying is.... abortion is a crime deterrent? 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

Soup, it's not just black women who have abortions-


Don't waste your breath. The stupid can't be educated. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

That's why we gave up on you long ago, Joey.

#bitterJoey 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

You go, girls of the court. It's a good day for the SCOTUS.

It's a good day for women. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

P.S. Thanks for the posting, Witchy. 

smartypants --- 10 years ago -

IMO opinion it is immoral to deny an innocent unique human life of its future, no matter the rational.

You say that as if it has something to do with this case. It doesn't.

Well done ladies! 

3rd generation hippie --- 10 years ago -


You say that as if it has something to do with this case. It doesn't



Indeed, it does not. Excellent point! 

3rd generation hippie --- 10 years ago -

This is the same "law" that Wendy Davis was filibustering, isn't it?

No wonder the Republicans are so quiet on this topic. It looks like they're going to get a well deserved whooping so that pathetic political maneuvering in an effort to circumvent a federal law that has been in effect since the 1970s. Smackdown time by Ginsburg! 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

You say that as if it has something to do with this case. It doesn't

If, or if it is not a human life, with an inaliable right to live its unique future is at the heart of every abortion debate.

Now I would like one of the pro choice group to look at my argument, and tell me what point is not true, or what part of the argument is illogical.

If the argument is not fallacious or illogical, why do you dismiss it? I think it is simply because you don,t like the answer, it does not fit your world view.

Conversely, I know of no logical argument against this position. All I have ever heard is a series of arbitrary man dertermined, movable lines 

witchywoman --- 10 years ago -

AMDG, this case is not about the right to have an abortion. Remember what the Republicans have said from the start. It's about what's necessary that a clinic should provide.

That is Smartypants' point. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

right. Soup, you know that's not what i said. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Witchy - thanks I understand that point. I disagree, make no mistake, this case is a thinly disguise referendum on the right to have an abortion by both sides. Just because it is not overt, don't think this is not what is starting to be addressed.

And, to that point. The cheering on this thread, is a cheer for abortion. My point continues to be, if you can not muster an argument against my position, what is the thoughtful basis for your belief, other than "that is what I think, because that is what I think".

And, I continue to wait for a challange that my premises are false, or my logic is bad.

Or, wait for some other cogen argument on another definition of the start of human life that does not contain establishing some arbitrary line. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

I've said all along that a woman's right to choose trumps the life of the fetus. Like it or not, that's my opinion. I am against late term abortions. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

So atd, even if that is a human life, you believe the mother has a right to end it at some point?

why that point, what makes it ok until some line, but not ok after some arbitrary line?

You know I think you are a good and thoughtful woman, and I respect you. But if a human life is in question don't you think you should be able to articulate a deeper rational, than "that is what I think" 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 10 years ago -

you and I disagree on when the fetus becomes a living being. The first 3 months, i consider it a fetus, unable to sustain itself, or even look like a human being. I know you believe it's a person from the moment the egg connects to the sperm. but I don't. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground