Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Corporal Punishment in schools? Yea or Nay?

who's talking here?

Red Heifer 2
CavemanBarney 2
Holling Vincoeur 2
Gigix4 1
Dorothy Parker 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Miss Understanding 1
TinktheSprite 2
sheddy 2
snowprincess 1
DatBoyHooD 7
Emperor of Kingwood 3
a889324uu 2
Butterbean 4
mutton 5
JimBecka 1
AMDG 5
fuzz81 2
Karras 1
Deplorable 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Corporal Punishment in schools? Yea or Nay?

What are you feelings on the idea of children being paddled by a teacher or principal as a form or discipline? Do you feel it would be effective? Why? If you're against it, why? I grew up in an era where this did not happen...and I fail to see the logic in why it would be a good thing. I'm hoping to see both sides of the debate.

Yes. I believe paddling a child instills a sense of right from wrong and will deter them from acting out again. Vote
 
 52.0% (13)
No. I believe paddling a child sends the wrong message and that form of discipline should be decided/handled by family only. Vote
 
 40.0% (10)
Meh...I'm not for it or against it, but, you better not hit MY kid! Vote
 
 4.0% (1)
Other...because, we need another option. Vote
 
 4.0% (1)
Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

What are you feelings on the idea of children being paddled by a teacher or principal as a form or discipline?

Do you feel it would be effective? Why?

If you're against it, why?

I grew up in an era where this did not happen...and I fail to see the logic in why it would be a good thing. I'm hoping to see both sides of the debate. 

DatBoyHooD --- 10 years ago -

Already posted my reason and how it made a positive impact in my life 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

0

For attitude adjustments 

a889324uu --- 10 years ago -

I don't physically assault my children, and I wouldn't allow anyone else to do it either. I wasn't abused as a child and countless studies have shown corporal punishment does not change behavior.

When people say they were hit and turned out fine, I disagree. I don't think they're OK. I feel sad for them that they think violence is acceptable. 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

Lighten up Snowflake. Schools don't want your social justice warriors either. 

a889324uu --- 10 years ago -

Uh oh, you mad? You want to beat your kids - you do you then. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

I don't think beating a child teaches anything other than it's ok to solve social problems with violence.

It also teaches the child that adults have the right to beat children. 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

Uh oh, you mad? You teach your kids to use both restrooms - you do you then. 

CavemanBarney --- 10 years ago -

A kid can be punished with a paddling without being "beaten". I think most people would consider hit in the face, knocked down, kicked, etc. as being beat. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

A kid can be punished with a paddling without being "beaten". I think most people would consider hit in the face, knocked down, kicked, etc. as being beat.

I can't disagree with that sentiment Barney.

The difficulty arises from who gets to judge. I know some who have suffered beatings with a belt or an extension cord or a 1/2 inch board and called that proper discipline.

I think that's crazy. 

Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

I'm trying to understand why a parent would want to have their child physically hit by a school faculty member.

Can someone who agrees with the idea explain this to me? 

CavemanBarney --- 10 years ago -

I got a spanking at school once, then got another one when I vot home. Never ever did the dumb thing I did, again. In todays society, by the time the child gets home from school, either the parent will forget or doesn't care. Heck, they can't even remember their child is still in the backseat of the car on a hot day. 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

Hippies... 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

Abuse. Bullying. Without a soundtrack it's impossible to have the facts.

The actions say abuse.

Edited to add: Hitting a 5 year old with a board is abuse. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

I'm not against a butt spanking /swat if necessary occasionally, and usually in terms of violation of safety issues. But I don't think any physical reprimands should be done by anyone but the parents. You can have punishments that aren't physical. 

DatBoyHooD --- 10 years ago -

Well look at the amount of violence that has escalated in school since corporal punishment was stopped. The problem with the liberal mindset (see jams and DP statements) is they feel you should "talk" to your kid not punish your kid for their behavior. Reminds me of the senator that said we should show terrorist love and they will not attack us . From my personal experience it took ONE paddle from my third grade teacher to know that I would NEVER f up in class again. 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

Spare the rod, spoil the child. How many drugs do you give your kids?

0 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Nay 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

Spare the rod, spoil the child.

Most think that's a reference to shepherds, with the rod.

I've never heard of a shepherd that beats his flock. 

TinktheSprite --- 10 years ago -

A spank is not a beating. 

Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

Is a "spank" with a wooden paddle by someone other than a parent ok? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

I'm not against a butt spanking

Nothing wrong with a little light spanking. The government should stay out of our bedrooms. 

Deplorable --- 10 years ago -

Do not "spank" a child in anger.

0 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Hey deplorable,

The question was in school, not sure there is quote for that one. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

I'm all for spanking, but anyone else ever tried to decide for me when my child deserved one would receive it in return 20 fold... 

DatBoyHooD --- 10 years ago -

The school would call the parents in advance (they have a permission on file) and get a verbal consent over the phone ..: once again we wouldn't have the selfish rude, obnoxious kids we have now if parents and the school would discipline more 

TinktheSprite --- 10 years ago -

Kids today have big fat mouths in school because they know the teacher has few ways to stop them. They are disrespectful of authority. There are no consequences for their actions often not at home, either. Parents want to be friends with their children. I generalize, of course. there are also a lot of good kids out there, too. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Completely agree with Tink. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I kind of think anything that starts with "kids today" has been said by every generation in one form or another.

That said, I probably say it 3 times a week myself 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Back in my day I had to walk 10 miles to school uphill both ways. 

JimBecka --- 10 years ago -

When I was working on my last graduate degree I had to do observations of principals for the Port Arthur and Beaumont school districts.

Port Arthur still has paddling. I talked with a PAISD elementary principal and he said the parents preferred paddling. They would rather get the punishment over and move on. He said he had done paddling for years and parents (and students) felt it was part of the educational process.

I talked with a Jasper principal and he said he moved from a district that did not do paddling to one that did. He said paddling made him nervous. One time he paddled an elementary kid and the student turned around and said: "Is that the best you can do?"

I think districts should decide for themselves whether they want to paddle. Parents have different expectation in different parts of the state. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Jim - irrespective of the district assume any parent can opt out? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Mine are all grown and gone, but I can tell you if any adult hit my children, they were going to have a very short, very direct, and very loud conversation with me.

I learned that from my father. My younger brother got slapped by a store owner in town. Knowing him, probably his fault. My father went into town after my mom told him about it. His intent was to tell the man that he should have told my dad and he would have handled it. The man started to yell back at dad, That was a mistake. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

And these days that would just escalate to someone getting shot 

DatBoyHooD --- 10 years ago -

Because kids don't have consequences for their actions at home or school. You didn't have the school violence 20 years ago. Parents and schools are scared to do anything, parents are worried about having cps called, schools are worried about being on the news for being insensitive. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

Speak for yourself...mine did, never had to lay a hand on them. All grew up just fine and two have finished college, one is headed for medical school. Can't relate...plus school violence has been most prevalent since the 80s and the introduction of hip hop. 

snowprincess --- 10 years ago -

More ADD and ADHD today- I wonder why?

Let's see, we feed our kids more processed, chemical filled crap than we did 30 years ago.

We used to have P.E. EVERYDAY and a full 30 minute recess.

We walked or rode our bikes to and from school.

We got home and immediately went outside to play for a few hours.

When you eat sugar filled crap food and are not physically active, you aren't going to be able to focus on schoolwork, but let's just drug kids up and beat them instead! 

mutton --- 10 years ago -

I remember a boy from elementary school. He would definitely be one with such a diagnosis now. But needless to say, we got through the lesson eventually. I think it is so easy to drug them up, and wonder how many truly are or just is easier to drug them up. Just because one is disruptive does not mean they have that diagnosis. Point in that the boy I knew may not have had the add/adhd but am sure some would have thought so! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground