Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What would you do if this was your kid?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Fiona 3
planemom 1
wayward1 1
LAXmom 2
Polly Ester 7
Perfection 8
AngieKaye 1
FANCY PANTS 3
Hiro Protagonist 5
Warren Peace 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 1
Dr Aborto 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
SwimSwim 1
idontplaynice 2
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
sheddy 2
FabFive 4
Just stuck 1
JAMS 3
Emperor of Kingwood 11
Ogre13 4
Beachbum 1
MarthaStewart 23
mrd16 2
The Master 5
Wicked 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

idontplaynice --- 12 years ago -

Girl sues parents for private school tuition and future college expenses. She says her parents kicked her out of their home. They say she is 18 and voluntarily moved out because they do not like her boyfriend. So she moves in with her friend whose father is a lawyer...hmmm

Does she have a case or is she just a spoiled brat?


Story 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

spoilt brat that needs a dose of true reality. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

Rachel ? an honor student, cheerleader, and lacrosse player.

Her suit also demands the following of the Cannings: that they take care of an outstanding $5,306 Morris Catholic tuition bill; pay their daughter?s current living and transportation expenses; and free up her existing college fund, as she?s already been accepted to several universities.


She?s demanding that we pay her bills but she doesn?t want to live at home, and she?s saying, ?I don?t want to live under your rules.?? The rules, he notes, include reconsidering her relationship with a boyfriend who may be a bad influence, being respectful, and abiding by her curfew. He and his wife, Elizabeth, who live in suburban Lincoln Park, about 25 miles outside of New York City, have kept their daughter?s car because they paid for it, says Canning, and he admits that they did stop paying Rachel's tuition at the private Morris Catholic High School.


The parents over played their hand and the daughter rebelled. While you can guide your children to see that their choices in friends and partners may not be the best for them dictating an end at 18 usually will not end well.

She is an honor student and they refused to continue to even pay for her high school tuition? Shame on them.

The court should make them continue paying her tuition at high school. Legally she is an adult at 18 and they do not legally owe her a college education. Morally I think they do and if there is a college fund for her I think they should allow her college expenses to be paid from it.

The parents are acting like spoiled children too. Because they don't like her choices they are willing to damage her and have her not only not graduate from high school but not be able to go to college.

Lets hope they don't have anymore children at home. 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

She is 18 and she moved out to live with a boy her parents don't approve of. In my humble opinion their financial obligation is over 

Beachbum --- 12 years ago -

Good. She wants to act like an adult so be responsible and take care of herself 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

She is 18 and she moved out to live with a boy her parents don't approve of. In my humble opinion their financial obligation is over?



Legally yes, morally they are just as bad as she is. They are suppose to be the adults. With as well as she is doing in school I think that surely there has been some mutually love and respect. They obviously didn't handle this well or this could have been avoided. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Her parents are probably obligated to pay the high school tuition since it was their purchase decision and the school can demonstrate their reasonable expectation that parents would pay for it. I can't imagine it would be anything other than a contractual obligation on her parents unless they informed the school that they will no longer pay. Their willing refusal to pay their debt would be a glaring symptom of irresponsible decision making on their part.

Mediation will probably result in college savings turned over to her.

Regardless of how spoiled the girl is, it looks like parents mismanaged this relationship. Kids do not get spoiled on their own. What result did they think would happen when expressing disapproval of her relationship with her boyfriend? It's hard enough to reason through an emotion, but to expect a teen girl to be capable of such a thing is beyond unreasonable. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

IMO the parents are responsible for the High School tuition. Other then that they are not responsible for her now. If she wants to live by her rules and not theirs then they should not have to fund her anymore. She has made her choice, to live as an adult with her boyfriend. Now it is time to get a job and pay her own way. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

IMO the parents are responsible for the High School tuition.

if she doesnt like their rules she can go to public schools and have a free education. a private school education is not a "right". 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

a private school education is not a "right".

I agree! 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

Regardless of how spoiled the girl is, it looks like parents mismanaged this relationship.

This is true. Parents should also realize that when they draw a line with a teen they have to know that they may end up with the very result they were trying to avoid.

However, we don't know what other things they tried in regard to her curfew violations and her disrespect. As far as the boyfriend, when parents try to demand that a 17 or 18 year old stop seeing someone they don't like, it often just brings them closer to that boyfriend/girlfriend.

I wonder if they went to any kind of counseling before kicking her out or did they just react and think it would end well?

The friends lawyer father that took her in to their home and is now suing them just sounds like someone who should have stayed out of it. They might have worked things out with their daughter if he had not encouraged her (which is what it sounds like to me) and paid her living expenses and tuition.

Taking in other people's kids who are having problems with their parents can just make it worse. no one forced him to take care of her and pay her bills. so IMO the parents should not have to reimburse him. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I'm 57 and the same rules were enforced with I lived at home with my parents. My brother decided he knew better than my parents and moved out his senior year of high school. He did move back once he realized obeying rules was a lot easier than trying to support himself. I respect these parents for standing their ground. They are not doing the easy thing. My parents worried constantly while my brother was out of the house. I had a neighbor who did the same thing. Her son was doing drugs and drinking and she said that wasn't allowed in her house. She changed the locks. I know how hard it was for her, but she stood her ground. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

if she doesnt like their rules she can go to public schools and have a free education. a private school education is not a "right".?


I would agree with that 100% if they hadn't put her in the school to begin with. I think moving schools 6 months shy of graduation is spiteful on their part.

She is an honor student who is also very involved in her school and still excelling.

The parents refusal to let her continue is equivalent to them throwing their own fit and wanting to injure her in the process because they also feel injured.

Someone needs to be the adult.

If they love their daughter they will at least allow her to finish school as long as her grades and prospects for college continue.

What happens beyond that should be negotiated. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

"Whoever has the gold makes the rules."

Wondering how bad the boyfriend might be. Could be he is such a scumbag that most here would do anything in their power to separate them. Just keep in mind we don't have all the information. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

The friends lawyer father that took her in to their home and is now suing them just sounds like someone who should have stayed out of it. They might have worked things out with their daughter if he had not encouraged her (which is what it sounds like to me) and paid her living expenses and tuition.

Taking in other people's kids who are having problems with their parents can just make it worse. no one forced him to take care of her and pay her bills. so IMO the parents should not have to reimburse him.?




I completely agree with this and think they should counter sue him for parental alienation. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

Wondering how bad the boyfriend might be. Could be he is such a scumbag that most here would do anything in their power to separate them. Just keep in mind we don't have all the information.


This is the comment from the father.

"reconsidering her relationship with a boyfriend who may be a bad influence"


May be a bad influence doesn't sound like solid ground. Sounds like he just wasn't their choice for her. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Either way, the case will be interesting.

Prediction: She may win on the high school costs, but I doubt she does on the college.

Caveat: Unless this is in NY or CA. In which case, I'm not even gonna guess which way this goes... bloody court could find that the parents owe their children a lifetime income. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

May be a bad influence doesn't sound like solid ground. Sounds like he just wasn't their choice for her.?

He is being sued. I'm sure his lawyer has advised him to keep the tone as neutral as possible. I bet there is much much more to the story. (there always is). 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Ah...New York.... Nope, no bet. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

Prediction: She may win on the high school costs, but I doubt she does on the college.?


It will be interesting indeed. If the lawyer is good I think she will also get the college account if in her name and promised to be used for her. In Texas I think she would get it based on her grades being her part of the deal and Texas ruling on verbal agreements. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

He is being sued. I'm sure his lawyer has advised him to keep the tone as neutral as possible.

If I were his lawyer I'd tell him to just keep his trap SHUT and refer all questions to my office. At my last law firm we'd require clients to sign a contract to that effect and if they spoke to ANYONE (even their own mothers) outside our office about the case, we could fire the client and keep all retainers. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Could go either way. Depends on the judge. Some of them like to make up laws. I don't even think some of them even make an attempt to rule based on law.

Enjoyed the discussion, now I must get into work. UGH. Busy day for me. Meetings. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

May be a bad influence doesn't sound like solid ground. Sounds like he just wasn't their choice for her.?

He is being sued. I'm sure his lawyer has advised him to keep the tone as neutral as possible. I bet there is much much more to the story. (there always is).?



Who is being sued the lawyer or the boyfriend? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Sounds like the attorneys will be the ones making the money here. The relationship is broken. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

Who is being sued the lawyer or the boyfriend??

The father is being sued. His daughter is living with a girl friend and her family. That friend's dad is a lawyer and he is the one representing the daughter. 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

Who is being sued the lawyer or the boyfriend??

The father is being sued. His daughter is living with a girl friend and her family. That friend's dad is a lawyer and he is the one representing the daughter.?



Yeah ok I knew that part. I thought he was replying to my comment that I would sue the attorney for parental alienation for taking her in and convincing her to sue her parents. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

She is 18, she is an adult, why is she suing to be treated as a child? 

MarthaStewart --- 12 years ago -

She is 18, she is an adult, why is she suing to be treated as a child??




She is still in high school. 

mrd16 --- 12 years ago -

this is everyone's fault....parents for raising a spoiled brat who is "in love" and then sues her parents, and the girl for thinking she is owed anything in life after 18..I can understand the high school thing, because the parents alread committed to it so they should honor that...but after that no way... 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

She is 18, she is an adult, why is she suing to be treated as a child?

She wants to have her cake and eat it too. She wants it all her way. She decided to move out of her parents home so that she would not have to live under her parents rules. She is not entitled to their money after she moved out. Even if she were 16, if she moved out they should not be responsible.

I wonder if the parents of her friend like the disrespectful things she does. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

She is still in high school.


That is irrelevant.

She can attend public schools for free. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Well since the parent of her friend is her attorney it seems they are okay with her attitude. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 12 years ago -

to live as an adult with her boyfriend.


She's not living with the boyfriend. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Caveat: Unless this is in NY or CA. In which case, I'm not even gonna guess which way this goes... bloody court could find that the parents owe their children a lifetime income.

Let's not forget that Texas excused a kids bad behavior based on Affluenza. Doesn't make us appears a lot better. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

Wow! She is a spoiled brat but also a product of her spoiled upbringing. I say, emancipate her and let her fend for herself. She is 18 years old. Time to grow up and lose the entitlement attitude. If the court determines the parents owe her, we are all in trouble. This is ridiculous! 

mrd16 --- 12 years ago -

she better watch her arse too....if this blows up and the media is all over it and follows it, I'm pretty sure she can kiss alot of future employers goodbye...who is gonna hire her knowing she is like this and will prob eventually sue the company for being mean to her... 

Hiro Protagonist --- 12 years ago -

I think the lawsuit is silly, but her parents are asses for throwing her out and not paying her high school tuition. She's obviously taken her school responsibilities seriously regardless of the "bad influence" of her boyfriend. I'm sure she didn't choose the high school she's been attending and excelling at. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Let's not forget that Texas excused a kids bad behavior based on Affluenza.

That's true, I'd forgotten about that idiocy. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

If they love their daughter they will at least allow her to finish school as long as her grades and prospects for college continue.

What a BS line for you to assume they don't love their daughter because the made a different decision than you would have.

My house, my rules. If you don't like it, then move on but MY money stays with me. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

The parents owe the money, they should pay it. It would be no different than buying a health club membership or something as a gift for someone, getting mad at them and then refusing to pay the monthly bill bc you got mad. You still owe the club their money.

There are many relationship issues at play here. These kind of things get complicated. Almost every parent of a teen has been through them dating someone they aren't crazy about, it's so common. But how you react to that is very important. Kids are in a process of emancipation their entire lives. You have to let them, it can be totally miserable at times but in the end the goal is always the same. And that is to keep a good relationship with your child and know when to let them go and learn things yet still be there for when they need you, and they WILL. You can't force yourself into areas they don't want you in. At the very least these parents should know at that age, there's about a 99.9% chance this relationship will be non permanent. Realizing that requires not freaking out when in actuality it will be for nothing, and the end result might seriously damage the relationship if you do. Not worth it.

But, she seems like a brat and she might be but her parents haven't exhibited the kind of behavior that kids respect. They have provided for her and all but they seem to have attached a lot of strings to their love. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground