Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should English be the official language of the United States?

who's talking here?

randyjet 6
d:-] 4
SoupIsGoodFood 8
Red Heifer 1
Perfection 3
FANCY PANTS 2
Hiro Protagonist 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
JohnLynch 1
RedMulch 2
I_won't_tell 2
Dr Aborto 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 7
WatchOut 1
Nightshade 1
sheddy 1
Charli 1
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Ogre13 4
Gigolo Bloodline 5
tennismommy 2
Not KU 1
Butterbean 7
Prolix Raconteur 1
mutton 3
Visitor 4
Kayry 1
JimBecka 3
AMDG 4
Wicked 1
Oregonian 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

A lawsuit filed in NY is suing NYPD because they did not translate a written complaint.

Should all official communication be in English here just like other countries have an official language as well. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Yes, English should be the official language of the USA. Everything should be in English first. This incident is the reason everyone should be able to speak English. That way no translator is needed in an emergency.

I do however feel it was negligent of the NYPD not to translate the woman's complaint.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/02/19/us/new-york-domestic-killing-warnings/ 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Its awful that her death was preventable. The cops should have translated the complaint. However, you shouldn't move to a country and not be able to communicate even the fact that your life and your children's life is in danger. The fault lies first with the murderer, second with the wife for not being able to protect her children by being able to communicate and lastly with the cops for failing to do their jobs and prevent this. Very sad situation. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Should English be the official language of the United States?

It will NEVER happen. As long as "We the people" are content to just get on KU and whine about it, instead of engaging our reps. Why should they put forth legislation if no one cares?

It only takes 15 mins to email Ted Poe.
Here is his contact info AGAIN:

Congressman Ted Poe
Harris County East

1801 Kingwood Drive, Suite 240
Kingwood, TX 77339
(281) 446-0242
(281) 446-0252 fax
(877) 446-0242 toll free

Perfection you started this thread. Do you have the time to break away from KU long enough to follow through? Or are you just venting? I dare you...double dog dare you to email, copy, paste your email right here! That goes for anyone that has commented on this thread. Are ya CHICKEN? YELLA-BELLIES? Go to his website and email him. If you got the stones.

Be respectful and to the point. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Are ya CHICKEN? YELLA-BELLIES?

No, I think by now they must have my number and dread answering the phone when I call. I have all their numbers programed in my cell phone. That way when I'm out and about they can hear what I think. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

FANCY PANTS --- 32 min ago - quote - hide comments
Yes, English should be the official language of the USA. Everything should be in English first. This incident is the reason everyone should be able to speak English. That way no translator is needed in an emergency.

I do however feel it was negligent of the NYPD not to translate the woman's complaint.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/02/19/us/new-york-domestic-killing-warnings/
TheUglyTruth --- 21 min ago - quote - hide comments
Its awful that her death was preventable. The cops should have translated the complaint. However, you shouldn't move to a country and not be able to communicate even the fact that your life and your children's life is in danger. The fault lies first with the murderer, second with the wife for not being able to protect her children by being able to communicate and lastly with the cops for failing to do their jobs and prevent this. Very sad situation.



I agree with both of you. 

Red Heifer --- 12 years ago -

No. And we're not like other countries. There is no one language of this country. Of course English is the dominant language and it is reasonable for people to expect to see and hear English. We dont need an "official" language except to make non-English speakers feel like second-class citizens. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I don't know how you succeed in this country without speaking English. 

Kayry --- 12 years ago -

YES 110% YES! Don't even get me started on jobs that aren't available unless you're bilingual!

Oops, did I just open up Pandoras Box... :O 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Millions upon millions of people came to this country in search of a better life without being able to speak English. Millions of us here are their desendants. It is one of the things that makes America great.

Almost all will be English speakers within one generation. Just like the previous emigrants. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

during previous generations migration to the US (particularly from Europe after WW2), the goal was to assimilate and learn english as soon as possible simply in order to survive...there was never the consideration that the US gvmnt had to accommodate your language or culture...people wanted to be "american"..

now many immigrants not only refuse to assimilate, they demand accommodation in the workplace and from the gvmt, whether it be multilingual signage, religious accommodations in the workplace etc...

they want all the best the US has to offer, but want to bring the very language and, in some cases, same religious and cultural climate they so desperately wanted to leave behind..

english should be the official language of the US...but many will say that is elitist, racist or some other BS.. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Ericb - haven't fact checked this, and admit could be all wet, but I would think most who come here for a new life for them and their children want to assimilate. They want to learn English, they want to work, and want their children to do become American.

Other than the multilingual signage - i am not sure of other work place accommodations. May well be some - just not aware of them.

I don't think this wave of immigration is much different than any other. The people who are here don't want them, and they do their best to survive, get a foot hold, and some acceptance. And in a generation or two they are assimilated. 

Charli --- 12 years ago -

Yes. An official language means ALL government business (driver's license, voting, court documents, etc.) is done in that, usually one, language. Would certainly save taxpayers a bundle on the cost of printing multilingual forms and documents.

Keep in mind, private business transactions would not be affected unless legal government documents would be involved. European countries have official languages for all their governing stuff and it does not halt economies. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Charli - think I might need a better reason than to save on printing costs to change this.

Not saying there is something "wrong" with having an official language. Just that IMO there is something very "right" in not having one. Shows our commitment to our heritage as a melting pot. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Good example. My 82 year old grandmother became a US citizen about 20-15 years ago. She can speak English barely enough to get by but feels more comfortable to read in Spanish. That includes ballots, amendments and other government documents that require reading. And yes, she votes every election. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

No.

We are a melting pot. English (American Version) is the primary language and will continue to be.

IMHO we can continue to be accommodating.

Border states have maintained a bilingual lifestyle for generations. Signs in border states are bilingual for the most part. French to the north and Spanish to the south.

When I walked on the Great Wall in China, signs were in 2 or more languages. Street signs in Beijing were in 2 or more languages.

Most families that immigrate here are English speakers within a generation or 2. Some are better at it than some of my relatives who have been in the US for a few generations now.

I hope the US will continue to be a global attraction for many reasons. If accommodating a multitude of languages can add to our culture, I'm all for it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Are ya CHICKEN? YELLA-BELLIES? Go to his website and email him. If you got the stones.

Why so hostile, mark?

I see him almost every time he's in town. In person. Face to face. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

We speak...


English ? 229 million
Spanish ? 35 million
Chinese languages ? 2.6 million +
Tagalog ? 1.5 million +
French ? 1.3 million
Vietnamese ? 1.3 million
German ? 1.1 million (High German)
Korean ? 1.0 million
Russian ? 881,000
Arabic ? 845,000
Italian ? 754,000
Portuguese ? 731,000
French Creole ? 659,000
Polish ? 594,000
Hindi ? 561,000
Japanese ? 445,000
Persian ? 397,000
Urdu ? 356,000
Gujarati ? 341,000
Greek ? 326,000
Serbo-Croatian ? 269,000
Armenian ? 243,000
Hebrew ? 222,000
Cambodian ? 202,000 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Some of you folk better be glad you don't live some place like Switzerland with FIVE official languages where you learn at least THREE of them in school. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

No.

We are a melting pot.


and when everything melts it becomes indistinguishable...which means we should have one official language... 

tennismommy --- 12 years ago -

Yes Yes Yrs 

tennismommy --- 12 years ago -

Yes Yes Yes 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

Yes, English should be the official language of the USA. Every government document should be printed ONLY in English.

Fixed it for you.

We (the people) should only pay for a document printing once. If you need the document customized to [your] language then you can pay a service to translate that for you. This could spawn an entire industry and would be a good economic boost. We're a republic so majority rules and most people speak English. Even the FAA requires that all radio communication be in English (for obvious reasons). 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

Good example. My 82 year old grandmother became a US citizen about 20-15 years ago. She can speak English barely enough to get by but feels more comfortable to read in Spanish. That includes ballots, amendments and other government documents that require reading. And yes, she votes every election.?

So I should pay additional taxes so that your grandmother isn't inconvenienced? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Is that really the only benefit for the change, to save on government printing? Wow, seems we have some bigger fish to fry before we get to the printing budget . 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

No. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Yo quiero Taco Bell...lol all I know cept the bad words. 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

Is that really the only benefit for the change, to save on government printing?

No, consider all of the multi-language services too.

As a country we have to decide what WE are going to pay for. WE should not be paying to accommodate everyone's language preference. Personal Responsibility must come into play at some point.

Read this  

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Any language change would include Puerto Rico and Guam, along with other territories.

Is the question only about continental US? 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

Any language change would include Puerto Rico and Guam, along with other territories.

They benefit from being a US territory, so the answer is a yes. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Mississippi river pilots and a significant number of ship captains on the Intracoastal Waterway communicate in Cajun. Would they be required to change?

In WWII, Apache indian "code talkers" provided an invaluable service to their country by speaking in the apache language. Would all military communications be required to be in American version of English? 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

In WWII, Apache indian "code talkers" provided an invaluable service to their country by speaking in the apache language

PLEASE, though I am not Navajo, I am sure that they would be outraged at giving credit to their bitter enemies, the Apache. In aviation, the REQUIRED language is English only and all pilots in the world must have their English proficiency noted on their licenses. So your thing about river pilots is moot since all relevant communications must be in English.

The problem with making English the only official language is that two states have Spanish as an official language, New Mexico, and Texas had Spanish as an official language as a republic. Then we have the problem of Puerto Rico, and Guam, not to mention Hawaii where the Hawaiian language is used a lot. My main concern is this needed? I think not and we have managed to survive this long without it. Let's try and use common sense first. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

I stand absolutely corrected for the error about the apache language. I accept the responsibility. Not quite true about bitter enemies, although some animosity existed.

Not to belabor a point, will American version of English be required in all official communications?

My English proficiency is not noted on my licenses. I hold several.

I also agree that we have done a pretty good job of accommodating our masses, and I would like common sense to prevail. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

. Not quite true about bitter enemies, although some animosity existed.

NOW I imagine that things are a lot more peaceful between the two tribes, but in the past, the Apaches killed Navajos on sight, and most other people too whites especially.

My English proficiency is not noted on my licenses. I hold several.

Don't let the FAA catch you with your outdated license. You were supposed to get a new one according to the CFRs or FARs. I put it off, and got caught and got written up for it. The line that shows your proficiency is right above your signature line on the back. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

A common language is the glue that binds a common culture and society. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Rjet 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

So your thing about river pilots is moot since all relevant communications must be in English.

UHhhh... RIVER PILOTS are NOT Aviators. Not covered by the FAA, but by the USCG.

That's not to say that English isn't a requirement for US Pilots, but I know of no law requiring it internationally. It would be goofy anyway since MOST Merchant ship captains are NOT American. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Can't type.

rjet:

Visited the Navaho territory a couple of years ago. Learned about code talkers. After the western indian wars, tribes became a bit friendlier toward one another.

Thanks for the heads up about the license.

We have similar views about designating a national language. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Navajo, I am sure that they would be outraged at giving credit to their bitter enemies, the Apache.

Navajo, Apache, Comanche.... whatever.... Some guy with a feather in his hair... like Disco Ken. :-P

Comanche - A Ute word that means "One who likes to fight me all the time." (Seriously, I did not make that up). Ain't grad school great... Do NOT play trivial pursuit with me. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

Yes! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground